When finishing the
book, The Handmaid’s Tale, the part I found myself questioning the most was
this execution. I found it rather odd that the women attending the Salvage are
not able to know the crimes of which these three women are accused of. Aunt
Lydia states on page 275, “… It has been the custom to precede with the actual
Salvagings with a detailed account of the crimes of which the prisoners stand
convicted. However, we have found that such a public account, especially when
televised, is invariable followed by a rash, if I may call it that, an outbreak
I should say, of exactly similar crimes…” This quote makes me feel that the
women of Gilead are not good enough or trusted enough to know what their fellow
Handmaid’s did. I feel it is another way the government keeps the people pushed
into the ground; by having them think they aren’t good enough or trusted enough
to hear the truth. It’s another way for the men running the system and the rich
women for that matter (Aunt Lydia, who obviously knows the truth) to remind the
rest of the women they are the unimportant ones in the greater scheme of
things. I know, if I was in Offred’s position, I would want to know the truth
on what actually happened; if the death of these women were actually justified
or something minor and blown out of proportion.
The man who was
beaten to death by the Handmaids, his reason for death was explicitly stated by
Aunt Lydia on page 278. “This man, has been convicted of rape. He was once a
Guardian. He has disgraced his uniform. He has abused his position of trust. His
partner in viciousness has already been shot….I might add that this crime
involved two of you and took place at gunpoint. It was also brutal. I will not
offend your ears with any details, except to say that one woman was pregnant
and the baby died.” I’m not sure exactly when his reasoning for death was
stated and the woman’s reason was not said. Maybe it shows that men can handle
the truth and not get copycat ideas in their heads like women might. Also maybe,
showing that men are more emotionally stable than women. I’m not sure!!