Their Eyes Were Watching God by Zora Neale Hurston was one of my favorite
books to read this semester. It was full of love and tragedy of all kinds. The biggest
tragedy, I thought, was at the end when Janie shot her love, Tea Cake. While talking
in class, there were debates on why she killed him and why she felt like she
was at peace when everything was said and done. I think, personally, that she
felt like she was at peace because his suffering was over with and he was no longer
going to feel pain. Someone thought it was because she “killed” every husband
figure in the past, but I feel she was at peace not because she was rid of him,
but because she got rid of his suffering. Tea Cake did many things for Janie
during his lifetime. One of the biggest sacrifice was saving her from the rabid
dog when they were stuck in the middle of the hurricane. The rabid dog bit him
on the face and gave him rabies, which is why Tea Cake died. I really feel like
their love was real. “He leaped at the bucket at once. But this time, the sight
of the water was enough. He was on the kitchen floor in great agony when she
returned. She petted him, soothed him, and got him back into bed.” (Hurston
179)
In
this passage, I feel that Janie really does care for Tea Cake. No matter how
hard he tries to cover up the fact that he is suffering, she can tell and she
is there to comfort him and help him. This is not how she acted toward Jody
when he fell ill and all she did was make him feel like crap by bringing up how
wrongly he had treated her. With Logan, she just up and left him for Jody and
had no remorse in doing so. All her actions are different with Tea Cake. I feel
Janie’s actions to kill Tea Cake was, yes to save herself, but I feel like she made the conscious decision to end
his life and his suffering before he grabbed the pistol. She loved him enough
to put an end to his misery.
I appreciate how you put Janie's last act with tea Cake in the context of her other actions with him and her previous husbands.
ReplyDeleteI really like how you pointed out that Janie killed him to end his suffering. Yes, if she hadn't, she would have died, but it was more out of pity than anything. There was nothing else anybody could do for him so I think this was Janie's last act of true love-killing him.
ReplyDelete